Poopy diapers stink. Like, really stink, especially if you leave them around overnight. And as your baby gets older, the smell will get progressively worse - by the time they are about a year old, their poop starts to smell really heinous.
How do you take care of the problem? The obvious solution is to take your dirty diaper out to the garage, dumpster, or outside garbage can every time you change a diaper. That strategy will work for about a day. Then reality will set in - nobody has the time or energy to take out every single diaper, especially when you're changing your baby every hour or two!
Thus the diaper pail. There are dozens of options. The Playtex Diaper Genie, the Munchkin Diaper Pail, the Diaper Dekor pail, the Tommee Tippee, the Diaper Champ, the Ubbi Pail, Safety First Easy Saver, One N Done, and the list goes on. Some of these are convenient, some not. Some great at masking odors, some not. Some durable and reliable, some not. Some requiring propietary bags, some letting you use whatever bag you want. So many options, and lots of differences between them. Let us help you out. We got a group of 22 moms together - some on their first baby, some well into their third. They voiced a lot of opinions! We consolidated and rank ordered.
Here are the best diaper pails of 2016!
Before we start the list, let's get something straight. Nothing other than a hermetically sealed chamber or being upwind is going to stop the stink of soiled diapers. Diaper pails are not miracle workers, they just give you a couple more days before you need to do the inevitable. Keep that in mind - none of these are perfectly sealed stink preventers. It's just not feasible. And everytime you open it up to put in a new diaper, you'll see (errr smell) what I mean.
1. Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail, in tons of colors. This is an awesome diaper pail, one of the best-rated and best-selling units on the market. And for good reason. Ubbi used steel instead of plastic to lower the chance of odors being absorbed, along with rubber seals at all the important joints to make sure odors stay inside. In our testing, this pail was the best at holding odors from dirty diapers, and we think that is the #1 most important factor to consider here. Of course, when we opened it the odor wafted out, but that's like any other pail on the market. This pail allows you to use any bags you'd like - when we tested it, we used standard tall-size kitchen bags. We think the Glad OdorShield Febreeze trash bags are excellent for this, and they are pretty reasonably priced (you can see them here). The lid is the only one that slides open, which is not quite as easy as the Dekor or Genie, but more manageable than the Tippee when you have a diaper in your hand. Slide the lid back, throw in the diaper, then slide it closed. This diaper pail is very sturdy and feels well constructed. It has a baby-proof knob on the top to prevent kids from opening it up entirely. Emptying the bag was easy, lifting the lid and the ring, and then simply tying the bag and pulling it out. Overall, this is the overall best diaper pail on the market, with the Dekor coming in as a close runner-up. The only real downfall is that it doesn't have a foot pedal. But if you have any issues with it, Ubbi is super responsive and has a track record for excellent customer service, so send them a message and they will fix any problems you have.
2. Diaper Dekor Kolor Plus Pail, in multiple colors. This is a stylish and sleek alternative to the typical (and ugly) Champ and Genie pails. It functions much like the Genie, but is a bit more durable. You press the foot lever for hands-free operation, which opens up the top and exposes a square flap hiding the hole where you'll toss the dirty diaper. The flap is a nice touch: unlike the Genie, when you push the foot lever, it doesn't immediately give you a giant waft of odor. That's because the stink is hiding behind yet another layer of plastic. Slick. When you fill it up, you open the front of the pail and pull the bag down, cut it with a little kid-safe blade, and knot it. Then pull down a fresh bag and knot it. Very similar to the Genie in this ring concept for bag dispensing. But much more durable than the Genie, and less stink escaping when you use the foot lever. Moms loved that it was completely hands free, so you can hold your baby and put in the diaper (the Genie is also hands-free, but the Champ requires a hand). Two moms noted that they bought the Diaper Dekor system after their Diaper Genie broke - usually the flap hinges are the first to go. So this system overall is highly recommended, and as a bonus it looks quite a bit better than the others and comes in multiple colors. We found it at Amazon for a good price. We did the calculations for you, and the cost of bag refills is about 1 cent per diaper. Note that they also have an "XL" version for $30 more that can hold even more diapers. Downfalls? Well, it's not as sturdy as the Ubbi, and because it's built with plastic it tends to absorb smells worse than the Ubbi.
3. Tommee Tippee Simplee Diaper Pail . This is new for the 2016 model year, introducing Tommee Tippee's first venture into the diaper pail market. Tommee Tippee is known for making high quality, reliable, safe, and inexpensive products; their products make it onto many of our top 5 lists, such as with their awesome baby bottles. The Tommee Tippee pail is most comparable to the Diaper Dekor product, using the ring-shape refill cartridge and having a nicer style than the Genie or Champ. Also like the Dekor, it uses a two-layer odor protection: the top lid that pops up, and a small flap that you push the diaper through in order to get it into the bag, which helps you avoid the waft of diaper odor whenever you open the top lid. Unlike the Dekor, however, this unit requires you to pop open the top with your hand (there is no foot lever on the bottom); that is why this is #3 on the list, since the Dekor is a bit more convenient in that regard. The Dekor and Ubbi lids are much more manageable. However, right now this pail is the cheapest on the list, coming in at under $20 with free shipping! So while this system is not quite as good as the Ubbi or Diaper Dekor, it is much cheaper. Also, we did the bag refill cartridge calculations for you, with the cost of about 2.5 cents per diaper.
4. The Diaper One N Done . Don't let the picture fool you, this thing is really compact! Here's a new entry into the diaper pail market, with a very different strategy. Instead of having a separate large container to store diapers, this system lets you use your existing garbage can. It reminds us a bit of having a puppy: you individually wrap each offensive item into a small plastic bag, then throw in the garbage. So the Diaper One N Done is substantially smaller than any other diaper pail on our list. Because it's not really a diaper pail. It combines a perforated roll of bags, much like those little doggie clean-up bag rolls. So you open a new bag and put it over the pail edges (similar to what you probably do already with the bathroom garbage can!). Then you put a dirty diaper in, tie it, rip the bag off the roll, and put a fresh new bag over the edge. Then you throw the bagged diaper into your regular garbage can. So it seems like a bit more work, but here's how our interviewed moms saw it... first, the system is about half the price of the others. Second, since you're using your regular garbage, you don't have to worry about taking out yet another pail full of garbage. Third, since it's bagged and tied, the stink actually does an OK job staying in the bag. Fourth, it is a really small pail that can sit on top of your changing table, or using the hook can hang on the side. So there are a lot of positives with the Diaper One N Done. The negatives? Well, if the Champ is unfortunate because it requires 1 hand to operate, the One N Done really loses out because it requires both hands to tie the bag and put on a new bag. But if you foresee yourself being able to put down your baby while you tie the bag, then this is the system for you. It's about $30 on Amazon right now. We did the math for you, and the cost of refills is about 6 cents per diaper.
5. Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe . It was a hard decision to make this #5, as it is basically tied with the Diaper Genie (below). The Diaper Genie and Diaper Champ are the most common diaper pails money can buy - they are at all baby stores, and they do a pretty decent job. The biggest distinction between the two is that the Genie isn't very well made and tends to break after 6-8 months of use, and the Champ doesn't have hands-free operation. The Diaper Champ uses a handle that you pull up on to expose a little pouch where you place the diaper: when you push the handle down, the pouch turns upside-down and drops the diaper into the pail. Clever design, especially since you don't need to open the pail and expose all the dirty diapers to the air. Our moms said that the Champ blocks odors considerably better than the Genie, mostly because it doesn't open up the entire pail every time you use it. Another huge bonus they mentioned is that while you can certainly use the Baby Trend Diaper Champ refills, you don't need to: you can use a regular size kitchen garbage bag, and it works just fine. Since you can use you own garbage bags and the smell is a bit better contained, the Champ beat out the Genie by a slim margin. The Champ sells for about $30-40 online. Comes in pink or blue. Refills amount to about 3 cents per diaper.
6. Playtex Diaper Genie Elite Pail . So this is roughly tied with the Diaper Champ, but we thought the Champ just marginally edged out the Genie. Maybe it just depends on what you prioritize in a diaper pail. If you really want hands-free operation, you need to go with the Diaper Dekor or the Diaper Genie, which both let you hold your baby with one hand and the dirty diaper with the other, and press a convenient foot lever. The Genie is a great product, and has a nice operation, and does a decent job containing odors. But it also doesn't contain odors quite as well as the Champ since it only has one layer of plastic (the top flap) between your room and the bag of diapers. The Diaper Dekor has 2 layers, and the Champ uses a rotating pouch system. But if you don't know any better, the Genie does a good job containing odors and features super convenient hands-free operation. Our moms also pointed out, however, that the Genie is not the most durable system, and several moms mentioned that hinges holding on the top flap/lid broke after less than 1 year of use. It also requires you to use their refill rings. By comparison, the Champ doesn't seem to ever break, and you can BYOB (bags not beer, of course!). The Genie is about $30 online, and refills amount to about 2 cents each.