While there is often a great deal of focus on the nursery, new parents must also consider a closer sleeping space for the baby’s first months. The American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines encourage parents to “keep baby's sleep area in the same room where you sleep for the first 6 months or, ideally, for the first year. Place your baby's crib, bassinet, portable crib, or play yard in your bedroom, close to your bed. The AAP recommends room sharing because it can decrease the risk of SIDS by as much as 50% and is much safer than bed sharing. In addition, room sharing will make it easier for you to feed, comfort, and watch your baby.”
Bassinets are crib alternatives that may appeal to parents for a number of reasons, including space, design, and lifestyle choices. Here are some comparisons and tips for selecting the best bassinet sleep space for a new baby. When you're done, be sure to check out our list of the best baby bassinets!
Bassinet vs. Crib: Advantages of Buying a Bassinet
Furniture Footprint: A bassinet will take up considerably less space than a full size crib or even a portable crib. Bassinets are often compact, and will fit more easily in the parent’s bedroom.
Co sleeping is easier: Because of their small footprint, bassinets facilitate co sleeping for new parents. Many bassinet options will fit snugly beside a parent’s bed, and some models will swivel in closer to make nighttime feedings even easier.
Easier to lay baby into a basinet: Bassinets tend to be shallower than cribs and play yards, so parents will often have an easier time leaning in to put the baby to bed. This is especially important for mothers who have had a C-section, as some leaning and bending may be uncomfortable or prohibited until the surgical stitching heals.
Basinets are more portable: Unlike play yards, which may require collapsing and re-assembly when moved, many bassinets are easily moved from one room to another. Often bassinets are compact enough to be simply carried to another room. Additionally, some bassinet models have a lift-away option allowing parents to remove just the sleeping space from its stand.
Shades for naptime: Hoods and shades are common features for many bassinet models and offer a low-light space to help babies nap.
Cozy: Babies are typically comforted by closeness and feeling snug as it reminds them of the womb—this is why swaddling can help calm infants. Thus, some babies may sleep better in a bassinet’s narrower sleeping area.
Gentle Motion: The option for motion can be a game changer for parents deciding between a crib and a bassinet. Motion options for bassinets include cradles, rockers, and mechanical movements.
Bassinet vs. Crib: Disadvantages of buying a basinet
Babies grow quickly: When compared to cribs, bassinets will include much lower weight restrictions along with other safety guidelines. Babies grow very quickly in their early months, and many parents may find their baby soon exceeding the weight limits—usually around age six months.
Less stretching space: While most babies prefer a tight swaddle and the comfort of a snug space, there are some babies who prefer to stretch out. These babies may not appreciate the coziness of a basinet. Additionally, these babies may wake easily when trying to stretch and bumping arms or legs on the bassinet walls.
Types of Bassinets
Bassinets and other compact crib alternatives are available in a variety of styles, each with their own advantages and drawbacks. Here are the most prevalent models.
- Pros: These units are sturdy with a strong frame. Many stationary bassinets include a storage feature under the basket, increasing the space saving opportunity. Some stationary models include wheels to facilitate easy moving.
- Cons: As stationary bassinets are designed with a strong footprint, some models may be wider than other bassinet styles, making them more difficult to fit beside the parents’ bed (depending on room space and layout). Parent reviews on some stationary models demonstrate concern for the thinness of included mattress pads. However, in a SIDS prevention article, the Mayo Clinic reminds parents to, “Use a firm mattress and avoid placing your baby on thick, fluffy padding, such as lambskin or a thick quilt. Don't leave pillows, fluffy toys or stuffed animals in the crib. These can interfere with breathing if your baby's face presses against them.” Concerns for baby’s comfort on included mattresses can be discussed the family’s pediatrician for medical safety advice.
- Pros: Cradles and rocking bassinets offer a lulling motion to soothe babies to sleep. Many rocking models also include a gentle vibration feature for added relaxation, and some even include a suspension system to rock naturally in response to baby’s movements. Certain rocking sleepers include a built in incline which can be particularly helpful for colicky babies and babies with acid reflux.
- Cons: As with all crib alternatives, cradle bassinets will be outgrown and require a crib when baby meets the size/ weight limitations. However, more than other bassinet styles, parents may notice a greater struggle when transitioning from cradle to crib, as baby may become accustomed to the soothing movements. Models with music, vibration, and automatic rocking features will require frequent battery replacements. For this reason, parents interested in this type of cradle should sincerely consider a quality set of rechargeable batteries. Due to space needed for rocking, most cradle styles will need to be placed farther from the parents’ bed, which will mean parents will need to get out of bed to access baby for nighttime soothing and feeding.
- Pros: Due to “the possibility of suffocation, strangulation, and entrapment“ the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends, “infants sleep in the parents’ room, close to the parents’ bed, but on a separate surface designed for infants.” For this reason, co-sleepers are a great option to get the closeness in a safe manner. Co-sleepers are designed to position directly at the bedside with adjustable height features for the perfect fit. Some co-sleeper models even include a movable sidewall for instant access to baby without getting up at all. This can be particularly important for breast feeding moms who are still resting and healing from a C-section. According to the Mayo Clinic, “[Moms] can begin breast-feeding almost immediately after the C-section. One breast feeding position that works well during C-section recovery includes side-lie holding. Lie on your side and place your baby on his or her side, facing your breast. Support your baby with one hand. Once your baby latches on, use one arm to support your own head and the other to help support the baby.” The co-sleeper option would facilitate this practice, supporting both healing and breastfeeding.
- Cons: Some co-sleepers overlap the bedside*, reducing sleeping space for the parent(s). While some parents may find sleeping so near the baby, others may find it negatively impacts sleep quality as they try not to move or make too much noise for fear of waking the child. Additionally, concerns for self-soothing development arise when babies are eventually transitioned into a crib after being so close to parents for the first 6 months - 1 year.
*An important note regarding the difference between bedside sleepers and in-bed sleepers as observed in the Journal Pediatrics by the AAP: “Bedside sleepers are attached to the side of the parental bed. The CPSC has published safety standards for these products, and they may be considered by some parents as an option. However, there are no CPSC safety standards for in-bed sleepers. The task force cannot make a recommendation for or against the use of either bedside sleepers or in-bed sleepers, because there have been no studies examining the association between these products and SIDS or unintentional injury and death, including suffocation.”
- Pros: For traveling families, or for houses/ bedrooms with limited extra space, a fold-away sleeper offers functionality while baby sleeps, and easily collapses for closet or under bed storage when not in use. Travel sleepers are often light weight, and some even include removable fabrics for machine washing.
- Cons: Travel bassinets tend to have a wide footprint when in use. This may be to support structural integrity for the light frames, but it can be nonetheless problematic for some spaces. Additionally, some travel sleepers lack deep pockets or storage baskets; certain models include no storage at all.
- Pros: There is no denying the photogenic qualities of these baskets. Found in a variety of materials from traditional wicker to modern mesh. Moses baskets (or badger baskets) are some of the smallest bedding options available. They are also some of the least expensive (depending on brand). Basket sleepers are lightweight and incredibly portable—often including handles, such as on the popular Badger Basket (pictured to the right). Most baskets can be placed on the floor for use, and stationary and rocking stands are available for some models.
- Cons: Mattresses for basket sleepers are not standardized, so finding replacements has been troublesome in the past. However, with newer basket options on the market, individual brands have begun offering replacement mattresses and pads for their models. There is some concern for safety with regards to semi-rigid basket models and carrying children in them, and these baskets were only added to U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission safety regulations in 2013.The modified standards now include, “bassinet/ cradle products that do not have legs and sit directly on the floor” with consideration for restraints and transportation. Because there is potential for some soft wicker frames to be pushed away from the mattress edge, parents may want to consider breathable mesh options for overnight use.
Choosing the Best Bassinet for Your Budget
Depending on style and model, bassinets can range in price from $50 to around $200, with some elite brands extending upwards of $250 and $300. Simple stationary models and travel option sleepers tend toward the lower price range. Rockers trend a bit pricier, as do quality Moses/ badger baskets (especially when considering the optional basket stands. On average, bedside co-sleepers are the priciest styles on the market. Basinets with high-end features like motion, music, and suspension will also carry higher price tags.
General Guidelines for Safe Sleeping
The American Academy of Pediatrics outlines safety measures to ensure a safe, comfortable sleeping environment for babies. Major points include:
- New babies should room-share, but not bed-share, for at least six months to a year. "If you do fall asleep, as soon as you wake up be sure to move the baby to his or her own bed.”
- Bassinets (as well as cribs) should include a firm sleep surface and a tight-fitting sheet. Babies should always be placed on their backs to sleep.
- Baby’s sleeping space should be bare. Soft bedding, bumpers, pillows, blankets, and soft toys can create a suffocation hazard.
Additionally, the Consumer Product Safety Commission advises that parents shopping for a bassinet should look for models which meet the following criteria:
- The bassinet should include a sturdy bottom with a wide base.
- All bassinet surfaces should be smooth.
- There should be no hardware sticking out on the bassinet.
- Bassinet mattresses must be firm and must fit tightly within the unit.
Bassinets that include wheels should also include strong, sturdy wheel locks. Parents should test these locks for security on all surfaces where the product will be in use.
Floor Surfaces and Center of Gravity
When setting up the bassinet, parents should check the unit’s center of gravity to ensure proper stability. Some lightweight bassinets may be easily bumped around or knocked over depending on the floor surface. Testing the unit’s stability will help ensure careful use.
Unless specifically designed for this purpose, parents should not move the unit with the child inside. Even if the bassinet includes handles, the baby still may shift and slip on the mattress, creating a strangulation and suffocation hazard. Parents should be sure to carefully read bassinet use instructions and safety guides, and stay aware of safety regulations.
Mattresses and Sheets
Parents should use only the mattress or pad provided by the manufacturer. If the mattress needs replacement, parents should search for an exact replica from the manufacturer or one that is specifically approved for their bassinet model. There should be no gaps between the mattress and the sides of the bassinet. Sheets should be fitted to the exact mattress size, and parents should never use a pillowcase or other un-fitted sheet to cover a bassinet mattress. Pro tip: Spit-up and diaper blow-outs are common, especially for newborns and infants. There may be nights you will need to change the baby’s sheet more than once. For this reason, parents should invest in at least three, fitted sheets for the bassinet—one for the wash, one for replacement, and one for backup.
In addition to safety guidelines for use and weight restrictions indicated on each product, parents will want to watch for developmental milestones indicating their child is ready to transition to a crib. When babies begin rolling over or pushing up on hands and knees, they are at risk of tipping over and/or falling out of the bassinet. For safety, parents should immediately transition to a crib at this point.
Stationary and rocking stands are available for many bassinet models, especially basket-style beds. When selecting a stand, parents should ensure the selected stand is approved by the manufacturer for use with the specific bassinet model. There are a variety of stand shapes available including ‘X’ frame collapsible stands, four-leg stands, and rocking stands. Depending on hinge quality, some X-frame stands may not be as sturdy as four-leg and rocking stands. However, four-leg and rocking stands are likely to take up more space than X-frame options.
Storage Caddies/ Organizers
Some bassinet models allow for attaching storage caddies and/ or diaper organizers. These optional features are often designed to clip and hang from the side of the bed. Smaller caddy options are simple, one or two pocket pouches to hold small, nighttime essentials. Medium sized storage caddies include more pockets and space, and the largest hanging organizers have reinforced shelving and multiple pockets for holding various items including lotions, bottles, toys, and large quantities of diapers. To prevent the risks of pinching and bassinet tipping, parents should ensure selected caddies are approved for their sleeper and avoid overfilling the storage unit. Any clip-on or hanging caddy should be positioned out of child’s reach and should be removed from the sleeping area when baby begins to push up on hands and knees.
Rainbows and Mobiles
Rainbow toy hangers and clip-on mobiles are available for many bassinet styles (some bassinets even come with these options included). Some battery-powered mobile options include lights and sounds. When selecting a mobile, parents should ensure their bassinet model is intended for attachments and can properly position and support the weight of the mobile. Additional specifications from KidsHealth indicate strings and ribbons on hanging mobiles and toys should not exceed 7 inches (18 centimeters) in length. Once baby is able to push up on hands and knees or reaches five months of age (whichever comes first) all hanging mobiles and toys should be removed from the sleeping area.
Incline Inserts and Wedges
Some bassinets come with “incline” inserts or wedges, designed to elevate baby’s head and torso. These products are generally intended for newborns or to help infants with congestion. As always, it is important that parents are vigilant and follow manufacturer specifications when using products. Parents should also be aware that the U. S. Consumer Product Safety Commission issued a warning regarding these products as they can become extremely dangerous once babies can roll over. The CPSC, therefore, urges consumers: Always use restraints and stop using these products as soon as an infant can roll over.