|Model and Link to Amazon||Our Rating|
|#1. WeeGiggles Foam Play Mat|
|#2. Wander & Roam Reversible Mat|
|#3. Baby Care Reversible Mat|
|#4. SoftTiles Play Mat|
|#5. Skip Hop Foam Mat|
Some of the playmats we tested were softer and more resilient than others, some had lower odor and off-gassing out of the package, some were more versatile in their inter-locking pieces, and some were made with higher quality manufacturing practices and the exclusion of toxic chemicals. Some were also safer for baby, only using larger parts that can't be placed fully into the mouth (more on that aspect later!).
Here are the Best Baby Play Mats of 2020!
Usually about $75 in the large size we tested (in black/grey/white colors, as pictured), or about $50 in a much smaller size that comes in a bunch of adorable colors like pinks, blues, greens, or black and white. This top-rated baby playmat has so many great things going for it, and received the most praise from our parent reviewers, our children, and from us! When we received the package, it became immediately apparent how large and high quality these foam tiles were. Each tile is about 24" x 24" square, and they are neatly packaged in a see-through plastic zippered bag with cloth edges and handles - even the packaging was cute. When we opened the packaging, we were impressed with two things. First, the tiles were really thick, like half an inch, making them super soft and cushioned. Second, the floor tiles had only a very mild odor, which is more than we can say for a few other play mats we tested. This likely has something to do with the fact that these mats are non-toxic, and do not contain BPA, phthalates, lead, latex, formaldehyde, or formamide. They are made from EVA foam. There are two ways to assemble the tiles together; the first way is to lay them all down on the floor, which makes a rectangular space that's about 5-feet wide and 7-feet long. The second way is to arrange the large square tiles on the floor, and use the edges as little walls to keep baby in a relatively contained space. The walls idea was great and well-executed, though it's not intended to keep the baby in that location, just better define a play space and keep balls and other rolling toys from quickly going out of baby's reach. In our hands-on tests, we found this Wee Giggles play mat to be well-constructed, super soft and cushioned, and really adorable with its gender-neutral greyscale animal prints. The animals were nice and large too, which means that when baby pulled them out they weren't small enough to fit all the way into a baby's mouth - we can't say the same for the little dots (in the holes of the number 8) on the alphabet play mat we tested! The slight texture to the mat was nice to make it relatively slip-free, and clean-up was easy with baby wipes or a damp cloth. A couple other things worth mentioning: you can buy multiple sets of these and connect them without any issues, the white portions can get dirty easily, and it is not reversible (the bottom is not textured like the top). Outside of that, the only other negative about this play mat is the price, coming in at around $75, which means that if you wanted to fill a normal-size room you might need to spend about $150. Overall, this is a fantastic play mat that will last you for several years of tummy time and play!
Usually about $145 in the large size we tested, making it one of the most expensive play mats on the market. The large size is about 78" long (6.5 feet) and 54" wide (4.5 feet). It comes in a few different patterns, the one we tested had a white and grey ikat print on one side and a white and grey stripe on the other; there is also a similar one available that replaces the grey with a dark blue pattern, but is otherwise identical. We received this play mat for testing in last year, and really loved it! Out of the box, the play mat took about 12 hours to flatten out: you remove the velcro straps, unroll it, and let it sit overnight with the curled-up edges facing down onto your floor. For us, that means we had the striped side up while it flattened it. We rolled it out at about 4pm and by the next morning it was completely flat. The texture and softness of the play mat is very similar to the Baby Care option, below, including the fine dimpled texture when you get up close to it. The size is pretty similar too, though this one is about 5" shorter in length. So if it's so similar, and the price is more, why is this option above the Baby Care? Well, a few reasons. First, there was basically zero off-gassing odor when we took it out of the box. This is one of the first things we noticed and it made us feel pretty good about it. Second, it is made from TPU foam, meaning that not only is it non-toxic and free of lead, latex, phthalates, and formaldehyde, it is also not made with PVC foam (which typically contains plasticizers/phthalates, polyvinyl chloride, and other toxic chemicals). So this seems to be a much safer alternative, at least for now, relative to PVC foam play mats available on the market. Third, it is made by a new, woman-owned small business that cares about their products and customers. And they will reply to your emails and concerns - go ahead and ask them a question on their Amazon listing and you'll see what I mean. Together, these three things make us feel pretty good about this product. Not to mention that the product itself is fantastic. In our testing, we found it to be soft, plush, durable, waterproof, and reasonably nice looking (well suited for use in a living room as much as in a play room). It's super easy to wipe clean, and it does have a bit of a grippy texture to it that helps keep it from being slippery (against your floor, and for your baby). Since we only recently received and tested this play mat, we will keep you updated regarding its durability after long-term use. Until then, we think you'll be really happy with this foam play mat, and strongly encourage you to check it out!
Usually about $110-150 in the large size we tested, or less than $100 in the smaller size. The large size is about 83" long (just under 7') and 55" wide (about 4.5'), and the smaller size is still pretty large at about 73" long (6') and 49" wide (about 4'). For reference, the large is about the same size as a queen mattress. These top rated playmats use an awesome concept: they are completely reversible, with one pattern on one side, and another pattern on the other. You can get two baby patterns, like shown in the picture on the right, or you can get a rug pattern (like chevrons, polka-dots, or floral design) on one side, and a baby pattern on the other. So there's some amazing versatility here. The one we tested had a blue moroccan rug pattern on one side, and an adorable alphabet and animal print on the other. When the moroccan rug pattern is showing, it looks like a normal area rug from a distance. Up close, of course, it's foam, so you won't be tricking anyone. When the baby rug pattern is showing, we were impressed by the cute patterns and texture. There are no interlocking blocks to deal with, no puzzle play mat pieces to fall out and get lost, so that's definitely a great way to design a play mat for parents who don't want to be reassembling and putting pieces back into the mat all the time. The foam itself is thick and soft for comfortable tummy time and play, the same thickness as the Wee Giggles play mat, at about half an inch. It arrives rolled up like a normal area rug, and it takes a couple days to get the corners to uncurl and settle down all the way - just let gravity do its job, just like with any new area rug. The odor was pretty mild out of the bag. The edges are tapered like a normal rug, rather than just a squared edge, which is nice. And it's waterproof and easy to clean - we used baby wipes to spot-clean it, but also took the vacuum cleaner right to it once to get rid of crumbs. You can't do that with the play mats with removable puzzle pieces, since they'll get sucked right into the vacuum. Like the Wee Giggles play mats, this play mat is also non-toxic and does not include BPA, phthalates, lead, latex, formaldehyde, or EVA; it does include PVC rubber. We found the foam cushioning super soft and absorbant, and over the course of a few months of testing, we found it to be durable and not prone to any color fading or scuffing. So there are no removable pieces, which on the one hand makes it easier to assemble, clean, and maintain, but on the other hand it isn't a toy like most other play mats, so kids won't have the fun visual and fine motor experience of popping out the shapes and putting them back in. Outside of that, the only other negative about this play mat is the price, coming in at about $100 to $150 depending on the size. Overall, we loved the concept of this reversible play mat, and also loved the softness, durability, and adorable patterns - definitely recommended!
Usually about $120 for a 78" x 78" (that's 6 feet by 6 feet square) playmat. Like the Wee Giggles play mat, each of the tiles is about 24" wide. Unlike the Wee Giggles, they interlock with each other to form a square rather than rectangle, so the space is 36 square feet whereas the Wee Giggles is 35 square feet. When they arrived for testing, we were impressed by a few things. First, this play mat is thicker than any other mat on this list, coming in at about 5/8" thick, so it's thicker by an eigth-inch than the Wee Giggles mat. You might not even realize that the surface is thicker, but it's worth mentioning. Second, it's really soft. Maybe it has to do with the thicker tiles, or a different type of foam, but it was really cushioned and soft. So soft that our dog's claws actually scratched it pretty quickly, but that was our own fault! Third, the colors are bright and vivid. While we show you the pink white carnation color option in the picture, this SoftTiles playmat is available in about a dozen other bright and adorable colors, all using the same animal patterns. Fourth, the edges are tapered so they slope down to your floor along the edge, which is nice and lowers the risk of tripping when walking onto the play mat. Finally, we liked the animal patterns, especially given that there were no small parts to get lost or worry about your baby sticking in their mouth. But that being said, the animals were also a bit harder to pull out and put back in because some of them have thin and long parts (like the monkey's tail) - not a big deal, but worth mentioning. Out of the box there was a bit more odor than some of the other mats on this list, but nothing major. Note that these foam play mat tiles are non-toxic, free of formamides, BPA, and phthalates. Other than the odor and intricate pieces to put in/pull out, the only other downside is the price. About $120 for a pretty simple 6 foot by 6 foot play mat? It's great, but we're not sure it's worth the cost - if you're going to spend that money, we prefer the Baby Care reversible play mat above. Overall, a great top rated playmat but a bit pricey for out tastes!
Usually about $80 for a 70" x 56" (that's about 5.5 feet by 4.5 feet). That's quite a bit smaller than most others, especially for the price. One of the interesting features of this interlocking foam play mat is that you can configure it in multiple designs (see the picture) to suit your interior design and also keep things interesting and novel. It comes with 40 triangular interlocking pieces, along with 30 edge pieces. That's a lot of pieces that your baby can pull up and wander around with (and to keep track of!), but the trade-off is that you can configure it in several ways. Out of the box, the pieces felt very thick (about 3/4" thick) and high quality, and we liked the thumb-style interlocking notches as opposed to the triangle-style ones that are on most play mats. There was no strong smell, and Skip Hop assured us that these EVA foam mats are non-toxic (and free of BPA, PVC, and pthalates) so they should be safe for your baby to pick up and chew on. When we put it together, we thought the pieces interlocked really easily with each other and without any gaps or awkwardness. After a week of use we didn't notice any discoloration or staining on the hardwood floor underneath, and the foam was durable and didn't show much sign of wear and tear. The only odd thing was that some of the white/cream color was mismatched, so when you placed them next to each other they were slightly different shades. It didn't bother us much, but we did think that for this price you should expect to get consistent color. Other cons? Well, it doesn't have edges that slope down to your floor, and it's a bit small for the price. Overall, we were happy to get our hands on this and test it, and we think it's a great idea to have multiple designs and configurations in a single set. If the price came down a bit and the quality control came up, we think it would be at a higher spot on our list. Interested? You can check out the Skip Hop Foam Play Mat here.
Usually about $70 for a playmat that's just under 5' x 6' (like 29 square feet). for a 78" x 78" (that's 6 feet by 6 feet square) playmat. This is a very unique play mat for our list, as it is actually folding - it folds up into a pretty small package that's about the size of one of the tiles from the Wee Giggles or SoftTiles play mats. So it's much easier to fold up and put away than any other play mat on this list, and it has a pretty small footprint for storage (unlike the Baby Care roll-out play mat). Another cool thing is that it's reversible, with one sie showing green fields with animals and ponds, and the other side being more interactive with a road network that toddlers will love to drive toy cars around on. Like the other play mats in this buying guide, the Hape play mats are non-toxic, free of phthalates, and had no strong off-gassing when it was new. But it's down here on the list for a few primary reasons. First, it's much thinner than the other play mats on this list, coming in at about 1/4" thick. Second, the folding seams are flimsy and it never really has a nice flat surface, which is a bummer when toddlers try to drive cars around on the roads. Third, speaking of the roads, the pattern repeats itself every couple feet, making it a little repetitive. Finally, it's a bit pricey given the smaller size and these limitations, coming in at around $70. But if you're looking for a portable play mat that's easy to fold up, this might be a good bet for you!
Soft foam floor play mats are a comfortable and fun baby essential, providing hours of tummy time, play time, and a soft crawling surface. They are the perfect addition to your play room, and have become an essential play room addition, much like storage bins and one of the best play kitchens! Play mats can encourage the development of gross motor skills by providing a forgiving surface to build confidence and buffer any little falls while learning to crawl and walk, and be a perfect place for trying out new baby gear like toys and activity centers. Most of them also are like a giant puzzle, helping your baby develop some fine motor skills and the hand-eye coordination involved in pulling out shapes and putting them back in. A top rated playmat will provide a safe and rich sensory environment for your infant, while also making it more comfortable for you when you're sitting on the floor playing for hours! Another bonus is that it can provide a nice slip-free surface for putting a good baby bouncer seat on.
We had a lot of fun buying and testing play mats, and we came to a pretty strong agreement about which were the best, and which were not so great. One of the things we did realize is that baby playmats tend to vary in safety, in terms of parts size and toxic ingredients, in size and cushioning, in price, and in function and durability. Another thing we realized is that if you're going to use a play mat on top of a rug or carpet, you'll want to do it only on really thin carpets or rugs. If it's too thick, then the play mat squishes into it in funny ways and contorts itself - and if it has interlocking pieces, they will pop up and out of each other as baby crawls across. So infant and toddler play mats are really best for either hard floors (hardwood, tile, linoleum) or really thin and dense carpeting (like berber carpets).
In addition to the top rated baby play mats reviewed above, we also tested out the Skip Hop Geo Playspot and were unimpressed with its quality and durability: it dented relatively easily and also tended to stretch itself apart along the joints. We were surprised given Skip Hop's otherwise stellar reputation for making awesome baby gear. Second, we also tested out the ProSource alphabet play mat, but were unimpressed that it contained formamide, a toxic ingredient used when making some EVA foams. Finally, we tested out the Exultimate Foam Play Mat, that we thought was adorable with its roads and buildings, but it was pretty flimsy and didn't come with any edge pieces so it looked very unfinished.